The following article appeared in the Dec. 13, 1973 issue of the Mt. Carroll
Mirror-Democrat. I couldn't resist sharing it with you. "Poffy's" is
now Charlie's. They have some of these same photos on the wall and some
neat info about Poffy.
Poffy's-Where Intellectuals Foregather
By Frances Chamberlain
Way back in 1923 a private
investor gave birth to a long-standing tradition in Mt. Carroll, Frank
Poffenberger, for $500 and out-standing debts, bought the pool hall from Charles
Julian. His business was carried on in the Adams building on Market St.
In those long, dry days, however, the pool-table was not the only source of
income. In the back room the walk-in-cooler held a few gallon jugs of profit for
the Poffenberger family. One visit from Sheriff Henry Shiley, unfortunately,
cost the business about $700. But, according to Frank's son Walter, "We only got
knocked off once". Paying a $700 fine for possession of liquor was fair warning
for the Poffenbergers-that was the only time they were caught.
After the days of Prohibition had passed, Frank paid, in October 1938, $100
for the back and front bar of the present tavern. Now that he was free to
contract business in an open manner he enlisted the help of his son, Walter.
Having
graduated from the Mt. Carroll Community School in 1929 Walter learned the ropes
of the bar-tending trade through real experience. He did not stay strictly in
the tavern business, however. A brief stint as a politician made his name even
more well known around town. In his campaign for mayor of Mt. Carroll in 1935,
Walter said., "I am against the utility company having any contracts or
franchise with the city for any great number of years, I prefer year -to-year
contracts. I shall do anything within my power to benefit the taxpayers- Economy
is my motto".
W. W. Hartman, incumbent in the Mayoral election received more votes than Leo
Robbe and Walter Poffenberger combined.
Walter left soon after that to spend 27 months in the Army, serving in the
3rd medical battalion during W.W II. He returned about 1946 and settled down to
the serious business funning the well-established Poffenberger tavern.
Business
grew and Walter expanded to the vending supply trade. He now manages 60
coin-operated machine in Stockton , Chadwick, Lanark and, of course, Mt.
Carroll.
In 1965 Frank Poffenberger died and Walter and his mother carried on the
business alone. On July 5, 1966, the moved the tavern down the street to its
present location.
Since the early days of the business Walter has served a large variety of
people in his capacity as bartender. He spoke with fondness of Mark Benney who
suggested the words "Where Intellectuals Foregather' as a motto for his bar
napkins. Mark Benney's book "Almost a Gentleman" as well as Robert Russell's
novel "To Catch An Angel' speak with familiarity of the tavern and of the
Poffenbergers.
As he thumbed through old copies of Excalibur and reminisced about the many
people he had known, Walter mentioned Hal Kirkby, professor of Science of Shimer
and Merlin Bowen who is now at the University of Chicago.
When asked what his thoughts were about the Mt. Carroll Community Walter
produced with a flourish a receipt for $1,000 paid to the Citizen's Save Shimer
Fund and said he felt "the entire city should support this cause."
Closing time, particularly, has become a confirmed tradition in Mt. Carroll
life. "You don't have to go but can't stay here" re-sounds throughout the
building as patrons prepare to take their final swallow and say a last few words
to a friend. As Walter says "I've got your dough, no go" everyone heads for the
door. Lights go out, good-byes are voiced and the chairs go up as Walter finally
says "Let's get out of this firetrap."